I Turned Down My Stepdad’s Gift To Please My Real Father — I Still Regret It Today

I’m Michelle — and for as long as I can remember, I’ve been balancing between two fathers.
One who gave me life… and one who gave me love.

When my parents divorced, I was still small enough to believe that goodbyes were temporary. My dad promised he’d always be there, and I believed him. But as the years passed, it wasn’t his car that pulled into the driveway for parent-teacher nights or soccer practice — it was Jack’s. My stepdad. Quiet, patient, and steady. He never tried to replace my dad, yet somehow, he became the anchor in a house built on broken promises.

Still, I clung to my real father. I wanted him to know he hadn’t been replaced. Every decision, every conversation, was filtered through one question — will this make Dad feel left out?

Then came my 21st birthday.
The day everything unraveled.

Jack handed me a small box with a set of keys inside — to a brand-new car. My dream car. My hands shook as I opened it. I could hardly speak. And in that same moment, I caught my real dad’s expression from across the room — the faint twitch of a smile that didn’t reach his eyes.

see more on the next page